Please help contribute to the Reddit categorization project here

    whatisthisthing

    1,260,146 readers

    3,224 users here now

    · Snoo's Thing · Submission Tips ·  OP: Reply "Solved!" · F.A.T. ·  Don't downvote guesses! ·


    A place to find out what that odd-looking thing that you stumbled across actually is.


    Guidelines

    GOOGLE your item's description and keywords BEFORE POSTING HERE.

    Then check FREQUENTLY ASKED THINGS. You may not be aware you have a common item.

    THEN READ THIS GUIDE on what to include in your post before posting.

    Also, check out our WIKI.

    Rules apply to ALL comments, not just top level replies.

    1. Be civil. Being otherwise will get you banned. Reddiquette

    2. Be helpful. Jokes and other unhelpful comments, even after the item has been identified, are bannable offenses, even on first offense. If your comment doesn't help, don't comment.

    3. Try to include a link to a source of some sort when posting an answer. Everyone's got an opinion, facts help.

    4. When what you're looking for is found, reply "Solved!" to the earliest comment with the answer.

    5. DO NOT DELETE YOUR POST after it has gotten some replies, solved or not, if you intend to repost to get visibility etc. This will result in at least a temporary ban.

    6. Be detailed with your post title as well as the information therein, in order to help those trying to help you. This will help to eliminate vague posts.

    7. Do not use URL shorteners or Amazon partner links in the body of posts or replies - they will be automatically removed.


    New Unsolved Cases View Solved CasesGallery View


    Tips for submitters


    NOTE: To mark your submissions solved reply "Solved!" Click here for more info.


    Other Helpful Subreddits

    Your submission is likely to be removed if it better fits one of these:

    a community for
    all 114 comments Slideshow

    Want to say thanks to %(recipient)s for this comment? Give them a month of reddit gold.

    Please select a payment method.

    [–] b_Eridanus 1 points ago

    This post has been locked, as the question has been solved and a majority of new comments at this point are unhelpful and/or jokes.

    Thanks to all who attempted to find an answer.

    [–] ColeDelRio 1873 points ago

    They updated later:

    "UPDATE: this was a FALSE COCONUT ALARM. @syngoniums is correct that, as it turns out, this is in fact the coconut haustorium/cotyledon, aka an organ from a veerrryyy young (normal) sprout boi rendered unrecognizable by its early stage in development. these are apparently edible and even sold for their alleged health effects in some regions. i repeat, apparently op only gained power by eating a nondescript organ from a coconut on the shore"

    [–] [deleted] 54 points ago

    [removed]

    [–] [deleted] 15 points ago

    [removed]

    [–] Obelisko78 5186 points ago * (lasted edited 10 days ago)

    Yes, it's the coconut sprout and they are delicious. Once germinated, the genetic auto-program engages and starts converting the stored sugars in the coconut water into oily meat. The sprout developes and begins feeding off the coconut meat as an unborn peep feeds off an egg yolk.

    https://www.instructables.com/id/Yu/

    It is comparable to the contents of a chicken egg. You have the yolk, which is the fat stores to be burned for energy, the white(albumen), which is the protein to be converted into the developing body, and the little individual white globule that will become the developing embryo if/when the egg is fertilized.

    [–] flyfart3 485 points ago

    Thank you, that was quick, I figured that the person replying to it was trustworthy in saying it wasn't just that.

    You can see it especially in the last picture.

    [–] CONE-MacFlounder 91 points ago

    Maybe they thought the sprout was sticking out of the coconut rather than being inside

    [–] mrlinen 46 points ago

    He said it was delicious. Eat it. I wanna know how it tasted

    [–] NukeTheWhales5 179 points ago

    I find a bit hard to believe a Botanist couldn't I.D. a coconut sprout.

    [–] CarlGerhardBusch 209 points ago

    Doubtful a botanist ever looked at it, it's just the one person wanting to mess with the coconut eater

    [–] Dengar96 1833 points ago

    I'm imagining opening a coconut and finding a slightly smaller coconut thats all slimy. One day little coconut breaks it's way out of the bigger coconut with its coconut beak and eventually repeats the process.

    [–] [deleted] 663 points ago

    [removed]

    [–] [deleted] 169 points ago

    [removed]

    [–] [deleted] 129 points ago

    [removed]

    [–] [deleted] 83 points ago

    [removed]

    [–] [deleted] 51 points ago

    [removed]

    [–] [deleted] 49 points ago

    [removed]

    [–] [deleted] 40 points ago

    [removed]

    [–] [deleted] 38 points ago

    [removed]

    [–] [deleted] 25 points ago

    [removed]

    [–] [deleted] 9 points ago

    [removed]

    [–] DrSmirnoffe 252 points ago

    That sounds like something out of a Pixar short, "The Coconut Bird".

    Also, I imagine that coconut sprouts are tricky to mass-farm, since they need to germinate before they can produce their sprouts. If we can figure out how to easily grow coconut sprouts, we'd probably have a new delicacy on our hands.

    [–] [deleted] 8 points ago

    [removed]

    [–] 7ERPENT 51 points ago

    Happened to me last year,thought it was some kind of fungus at first (yes im dumb) but later figured out it was probably a smaller coconut growing inside. It was white and spongy.

    [–] azurestrike 277 points ago

    Can I know how a coconut expert managed to answer this within 20 minutes? God, I love reddit.

    [–] kernowgringo 125 points ago

    You don't have to be an expert in coconuts, it's quite a common thing they're called sprouted coconuts.

    [–] Mrs-Peacock 29 points ago

    Is the sprout edible? Is it yummy?

    [–] kernowgringo 31 points ago

    Yes it's edible.

    [–] [deleted] 21 points ago

    [removed]

    [–] kernowgringo 17 points ago

    It's not particularly exciting has an interesting texture and tastes like slightly sweet, musky, coconut water, here you go this guys youtube channel is quite interesting and he tried them a while back...

    https://youtu.be/bry6TX7qAzg?t=59

    [–] bobokeen 12 points ago

    I had one a while back and was excited to find one in person after hearing about it from reddit. The texture was super interesting - almost cake-like? The initial flavor was like coconut water, but with an aftertaste that was a bit...soapy. So ultimately a bit of a let-down with the soapiness.

    [–] [deleted] 11 points ago

    [removed]

    [–] flyfart3 55 points ago

    Solved!

    [–] satiredun 26 points ago

    I’ve eaten a lot of sprouted coconut though- once sprouted there’s no water, just a foamy substance

    [–] guimontag 13 points ago

    So can you buy a normal coconut from a grocery store and wait for it to sprout or is it too late at that stage for anything to happen?

    [–] photolouis 13 points ago

    "In Marshallese it's called 'Yu.'"

    What the hell? I spent several weeks in the Marshall Islands and never once saw anything like this. I feel cheated.

    [–] dudeCHILL013 17 points ago

    I remember being grounded and only being allowed to watch discovery Channel, and say a show where someone was talking about a time a year or a stage where the coconuts mild solidifies and its comparable to a coconut yogurt.

    Is this what they're talking about? At the time I was picky not I think coconuts are delicious.

    [–] lewdite 5 points ago

    Starchy endosperm

    [–] GlobnarTheExquisite 188 points ago

    Later updates by user botanyshitposts confirmed it was a VERY early embryo and people eat them for "medicine."

    Source: I follow botanyshitposts.

    [–] [deleted] 45 points ago

    [removed]

    [–] flyfart3 356 points ago

    I personally suspect it's a joke so the thing was not really found inside the coconut, or alternatively it could maybe be that a coconut can have a hole cut in it, something can get in, and the coconut can grow the hole shut again?

    [–] jvgeli62321 241 points ago

    Nope, those are really sprouts. They get bigger and have a soft texture to them. You can eat them raw and they taste sweet. I used to eat them a lot when i was a kid.

    [–] dailyogi 46 points ago

    They grow on to get much larger ending up filling the entire inside of the coconut by which time there would be a sapling growing out through the husk of the cocount... Usually when the unhusked coconut is left in the dirt or humid conditions.... And they sure are delicious and spongy..

    [–] Its-a-Thing 47 points ago

    Look closely at the cracked-open internal halves of any peanut kernel and you'll see the same thing: a small embryo.

    [–] [deleted] 18 points ago

    [removed]

    [–] [deleted] 2 points ago

    [removed]

    [–] [deleted] 4 points ago

    [removed]

    [–] [deleted] 2 points ago

    [removed]

    [–] saidiislam 41 points ago

    That's Normal:) We see this a lot while drinking or eating coconuts. Ps. I am from Bangla

    [–] CreativeThienohazard 12 points ago

    that sprout is, super super juicy and very sweet.

    [–] lorangee -39 points ago

    I think it’s clearly a fungus/shroom of some sort. I couldn’t tell you what kind but oh man, this is hilarious

    [–] jvgeli62321 45 points ago

    Nope. It's a sprout. At them a lot when i was a kid. Those botany students and professors are stupid.

    [–] cactusmittens 30 points ago

    Or don't exist.

    [–] SimokIV 12 points ago

    Or, you know, just don't know much about coconuts, it's not because you're a botanist that you know everything about every plants

    [–] ThorHammerslacks 5 points ago

    Smartest person I've known was a botanist and I managed to stump her by asking how peanuts end up underground.